Excuse me guys, I was eating breakfast this morning when I came across the thought. The Boxster S and the F-Type are technically in the same price segment so what are the arguments for an against the other car?

For me I'd get a Porsche if they were the same price because I'm terribly biased for Porsche and I think the Porsche badge puts it on a different level compared to Jaguar.

What are your guys' opinions on it?