First I had to get the actual VIN, I remembered the last 7, but not the whole VIN. Off to bimmer.work it was:
Armed with the full VIN, I googled it. Where I came across this result:
CTRL + F lead me to this link:
So looks like someone sold my former 128i in April of this year after owning it for a little over two and half years and putting right around 17k on it for $10k. Ironically, if it was posted on April 7, that would be the same day the event that caused me to sell this car in the first place happened.