Illustration for article titled It is always winter now. (Advice needed)

Looks like the end of the road for my front left tire. I think the wheel may have made it out okay. There’s no visible damage to it. It happened not even on a pothole, just a normal road seam! Felt it all the way in my soul. Happened coming back from Hooptiecon/Radwood, of which pictures below.

Advertisement

Now here’s the conundrum I’m faced with:

The car has been riding on the Bridgestone DriveGuard run-flats that came with it, and they’ve been good to me. I’m more than satisfied with dry grip for driving around and they’re okay in the wet. To be honest, I had assumed they were summer tires until I went autocrossing a couple of weeks ago and 1) noticed the M+S designation and 2) was very disappointed in their autocross performance.

Advertisement

Since then, I had decided to switch to summer tires and probably non-runflats when the time came. No sense in getting rid of perfectly good tires prematurely. However, this unfortunate event puts me in a difficult position. I don’t even know what my options are.

Should I try replacing just the single tire? It’s one of the front ones, which means it’s 225/40RF18. TireRack has them at an eye-watering $225 a pop.

Advertisement

Could I swap out just both fronts? In that case, I would probably not go for the DriveGuards. However, is it okay to have summers in front and all-seasons in the back? Non-RFs in front and RFs in the back? What do I even need to buy to run non-RFs in a car without a jack?

The two summer options I’m looking at are Michelin Pilot Sport 4S and Continental ExtremeContact Sport. The Michelins seem to be slightly better but way more expensive. I think I’d be very happy with the Contis. I run ExtremeContact DWS 06s on my A4 and they’re great.

Advertisement

So here are the current options:

  • 1 front Bridgestone DriveGuard: $225.99
  • 2 front Bridgestone DriveGuard: $451.98
  • 2 front Continental ExtremeContact Sport: $329.98
  • 4 staggered Continental ExtremeContact Sport: $707.96
  • Some other brand for fronts or all?

What say you, oppo?

Radwood pics for your time. I didn’t really spend much time there because I had thought is was the last weekend of March so I didn’t plan on attending. I did not meet up with anybody.

Advertisement
Illustration for article titled It is always winter now. (Advice needed)
Illustration for article titled It is always winter now. (Advice needed)
Advertisement
Illustration for article titled It is always winter now. (Advice needed)
Seems to have been a lot of foot traffic around this one earlier in the day, based on the muddy prints.
Seems to have been a lot of foot traffic around this one earlier in the day, based on the muddy prints.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter