If I need one that is. Lets say the GP gets totaled, with a budget of say $5000 (tops) what would you buy?

Requirements:

Lowish miles (Under 125,000)

Automatic (needs to go to my little sister after this summer)

Sedan/coupe preferred.

Options are limited, saw a decent RSX, a crazy cheap Ls430, and a nice I35, but overall options seem thin at best.