Porsche Carrera S (or 4S, or Cabrio, or Targa) vs Porsche Macan Turbo ?

Sort of a strange comparison, I know, but my co-worker wants to get a Porsche, but needs 4 seats.

However, A) He has a very steep driveway both at home and at work, as well as his area just having awful roads, and B) His left leg is disabled, so no stick-shift.

As a result, this rules out the Turbo, Turbo S, GT3, GT3 RS, and GTS 911s. (He’s also not considering the Cayenne because it’s too big, nor the Panamera, because he doesn’t like how it looks haha)


Do you think the Macan Turbo is still a fun car, despite being sort of…not a car?

Do you think the Carrera S is fine as it is, or are there people out there who actually drive one and think, “You know, what this car needs is more horsepower.” Does the sum of its parts negate the fact that some of its competitors have more HP? What does the GTS have over the S that’s a must-have?

Which would you rather have?

Share This Story