The rear bumper will need replacing as well, unfortunately. Instead of popping out of the tabs, the trim piece just ripped them clean off. I’m worried that this means it’s flapping around on the highway and I might lose my tag. I’d put it in the rear window if it wasn’t tinted.
In any case, it looks much better now than my original quick fix.
Also, I have a giant spider zip-tied to the actual metal bumper. One neat thing I noticed is that there’s a license plate mount hidden back there. I’m half disappointed that I don’t get to use it. Except for spiders and bungee cords, anyway.