One of the more common topics typically asked on most car forums is advice on buying a used vehicle. One thing everyone has to remember is that buying any vehicle, whether it's new or used, is a highly personal experience. What I may be interested in purchasing may be completely different to someone else. I personally prefer owning older vehicles, partially because I generally prefer their styling and partially because they're (generally) easier and cheaper to work on. Purchasing a gently used vehicle can be a far more in-depth process than buying new, so that is what I'll be focusing on in this article. That's not to say that some of these tips won't work for new vehicles, however.

*Disclaimer* This is a copy/paste of an article I did for my local car club, thus it makes references to ICBC (British Columbia's insurance agency). While your insurance companies may work differently in certain aspects, chances are most of the information within this post is still relevant.

/disclaimer

What Style Best Suits Your Needs?

We've all seen posts asking for opinions of something like a NB Miata vs a BMW X3; In other words, two completely different vehicles. These drive all of us crazy because comparing the two models is basically impossible. The best thing to do when deciding to buy a vehicle is to figure out what you want. Are you looking for a family hauler, a canyon carver, a gas miser, or just something that's highly reliable? Asking whether Car A is better than SUV C or Wagon M is a test of futility. We can't tell you what will work best for your needs, so you need to figure it out on your own first. Also keep in mind that you don't necessarily have to settle for a jack of all trades just because you think you may need four doors or a truck bed once every six months. You can always buy a vehicle that suits most your needs and then rent another vehicle for a day.

Advertisement

Know Your Budget

When looking for a used vehicle, never look at the maximum end of your spending spectrum. No matter how pristine or well looked after a vehicle may be, there will always be something that will need to be addressed either immediately or down the road. The amount of money you hold back will largely depend on what sort of vehicle you're looking at and also the price bracket you're targeting. If you`re looking for a 90`s era Civic or Corolla, chances are you can get away with holding back $500. However, if you`re looking at a Mercedes S-Class or a Land Rover, those vehicles have some potentially very, very expensive repairs in the near future.

Advertisement

And that brings me neatly to my next point.

Common Problems aka Do Your Research

There are many things that are universal between makes and models that you should always look out for. Carproof, Carfax and Aircare records are one source of information when it comes to potential accidents or odometer rollbacks, but they only keep records of what they're given. Not every accident gets reported and not every vehicle has gone through an Aircare station. There are many things to keep an eye out for but the easily noticeable ones include mismatched paint, panel gaps that aren't even on both sides, mechanical parts that either aren't OEM or have yellow writing on them, and excessive wear and tear on a driver's seat/steering wheel/pedals/shifter even though the odometer indicates low mileage.

Advertisement

Another thing to look for is how well a vehicle has been maintained. Some owners are fastidious about keeping records and doing repair work on a set schedule, while other owners only fix things once they're broken down on the side of the road. While it's not 100% true, the likelihood of a car breaking down shortly after purchasing it from a fastidious owner drops dramatically compared to the other option. Regardless of the owner, you should always check out the car yourself or by a trusted friend or mechanic. If you don't have a friend who's able to help and your trusted mechanic is otherwise busy, check simple things like tire tread, brake pad thickness, if all the fluids are topped up (or at least nearly), any rust that may affect the structure, and all the electronic goodies inside the cabin. Also, check out the fuse box. If an owner is stating that there are some issues with said vehicle, a burnt fuse could be the single cause of it. Fuses are dirt cheap and extremely simple to replace. And if it saves you the hassle of having to pull half an engine apart to only determine that the knock sensor isn't the cause of an issue, even better.

While websites like Revscene are filled with members who are familiar with cars of all sorts, you're best searching out make or model specific forums where there are likely stickied threads with all sorts of information of what to look out for. Sites like VWVortex, NASIOC and the ilk can be the best source of help you will ever need. An R51 Nissan Pathfinder was prone to rust on the driver's side strut tower, various Honda's have automatic transmissions that are nothing but a grenade waiting to go off, and early models of the MK4 Jetta/Golf had several common issues with their VR6 engine and window regulators. What works perfectly well on most vehicles may be a serious issue on another. Never take something that works for granted on other vehicles because it could potentially be a headache waiting to happen. Always do your research.

Advertisement

Something to also remember is that just because a car is low mileage, that's not an indication that you won't have to repair it. The longer a car sits (or the shorter its weekly trip average is), the greater the chance that all the rubber needs to be replaced. Tires and gaskets all have a shelf life. Yes, gaskets don't need to be replaced as frequently as tires, but if they aren't kept lubed, they will dry out and crack. The same goes for the drive belts (though not in the same sense of having to be lubricated). They dry out and start cracking from a lack of use. While some belts are cheap and super easy to replace, others like timing belts and many serpentine belts on transverse engines can be time consuming and costly.

Hidden Gems

Sometimes when you're busy looking through Craigslist, Kijiji, Autotrader or Ebay, you'll come across a deal that seems too good to be true. And, honestly, most of the time it is. That mint, low mileage FD with an asking price of $4000 is probably owned by some Nigerian prince, who's more than happy to trade you that car (and his fortune!) for a small fee as soon as your banking information is exchanged. This is not always the case, however. It's always worth keeping an eye out for a hidden gem. If your initial contact with the owner seems legit with the information he gives you, don't hesitate to check it out. Chances are it will be gone if you wait a day or two, especially if it's a popular car with enthusiasts.

Advertisement

Rebuilds/Salvage Vehicles

A common misconception is that all cars with a rebuild or salvage title are to be avoided at all costs. While that perception is certain not unfounded, to blindly write off all vehicles with one of those two titles can be a mistake. To give a brief explanation, a salvage title is given to a vehicle that has been written off by ICBC for any number of reasons. Once the car has been inspected, it is then given a rebuild title. Naturally your first impression at seeing a rebuild title is to run away, all the while screaming bloody murder. No one would likely fault you for that reaction. However, going back to the hidden gem topic, you can occasionally find a rebuild that's actually worth buying.

Advertisement

I know we have members on here that have body shops and will occasionally rebuild an ICBC write-off, but to use a broad paintbrush here, a typical frame damaged vehicle will almost never be repaired properly. Sure, it may pass an inspection and be deemed road legal, but it can end up with alignment issues that will plague it for the rest of its life on the road. Other shops have been known to replace damaged parts with sub-par quality units, and even occasionally shops have been caught putting faulty airbags into cars simply in order to pass inspection. After all, inspectors wont test fire an airbag, so why bother spending all that money for something that will, in all likelihood, never be used? Personally I'd never buy a car for daily road use that had frame or pillar damage, but that's just me. No, what I'm trying to get at here are rebuilds from theft damage.

It's not uncommon for certain vehicles to have been written off due to theft. Plenty of cars come with Recaro or Bride seats, while others have BBS or other expensive OEM (but aftermarket built) rims. Usually the cost of replacing these items exceed the value that ICBC is willing to barter up to, so off to the wrecking yard these cars go. There's absolutely nothing wrong with these vehicles that a set of lower trim seats or rims won't fix, and because it's now got the rebuilt stigma attached to the title, you can occasionally find these cars for far less on the open market.

Advertisement

However, just like maintenance records, if the owner has either photos or shop records of what was actually done to the car, you're better off. Don't simply trust that the GTI you're buying was a theft recovery, only to realize down the road that it had a new back half stitch welded on.

Negotiating

The last part of buying a car is all about money. This is what the seller tends to dread, and the buyer looks forward to. I'm sure we've all sold something on Craigslist and have dealt with ridiculous lowball offers. Don't be that guy! Check out the pricing for similar vehicles online. If what the seller is asking happens to be in the same ballpark as the others, chances are extremely high that he won't accept a stupid low amount. If that vehicle is in very good mechanical and physical shape, and the owner knows it, he may not even drop his asking price a single penny. Cars will sell for what they're worth, or at least what the owner feels it's worth. I'm sure we've all scoffed at that member asking $30k for an R33 V-Spec, but if that's what the owner wants for it, then chances are he won't budge. By all means offer a lower amount that you feel is fair, but don't be offended if they laugh you off their driveway.

Advertisement

There's no exact science to determining how much you should counter-offer an asking price as it's all dependent on the market value and how determined the owner is to getting rid of it. You have to basically play it by ear after getting a feel for the car and the seller. I once bought a car that was advertised for $2000 for a paltry $300. Admittedly it was only good as a parts car, but luckily that's all I needed it for. Conversely, when I bought my Accord coupe a few years back, I paid full asking price because it was worth it. It all comes down to how good you are at negotiating and reading the other person.

Conclusion

As a first time buyer, looking for a new used car can seem like a daunting task. Many people, including myself, enjoy the challenge that it can be, but many more dread it. If there's one piece of advice that you should take home with you, even if you ignore everything else in this post, it's that you should never become attached to one vehicle. Never buy out of impulse or because the seller is saying that there's another interested party coming by in half an hour if you don't buy it. There will always be another car, another good deal, just waiting around the corner. Don't get yourself hyped into a situation that you will regret two blocks down the road.

Advertisement

Be patient, do your due diligence, and be fair when negotiating.

And stop asking if a Miata is a better choice than an X3.