I need to buy tires for my Coleman Sedona tent trailer. Currently, the trailer has its second set of crappy Loadstar tires that have gone from the Pacific to the Atlantic and back and have the terrible uneven wear to show for it. Upgrading to radials.

There are two choices, and the Carlisle clearly has a margin over the SuperCargo on paper, but according to the numbers, the SuperCargo would be plenty adequate and is $75 cheaper for a set of three tires. (Also need a spare.)

Anybody want to offer some thoughts on this?